A few years ago my daughter’s in-laws from Brooklyn, NY came to Memphis for Thanksgiving. To give them a taste of Southern cuisine, I decided to fry a turkey in addition to my conventionally roasted turkey. In effect, we had a taste panel where our twenty guests got to try both a roasted and fried turkey. There was no question that the fried turkey tasted better. It was more savory and had a richer flavor. It gave new meaning to the saying: “anything fried tastes better.” However, be careful! See below for my 6 tips to safely frying your turkey.
Fried turkeys are great, but frying the turkey is seriously dangerous. Every year deep-fryer fires are responsible for five deaths, 60 injuries, the destruction of 900 homes, and more than $15-million in property damage, according to the National Fire Protection Association.
Here are six basic tips to frying a turkey the safest way possible:
Get a turkey that fits in your fryer
A turkey in the 12 to 15-pound range will work well. Most turkey fryers will fit a turkey of fewer than 15 pounds. Larger turkeys increase the chances of oil overflow. The smaller turkey also cooks quicker and more evenly. If you are having a larger crowd you may need to fry more than one turkey. The good news is that it only takes about 35 to 45 minutes to fry a turkey, so cooking two should be no problem.
Make sure your turkey is fully defrosted and brought to room temperature
If you want a real disaster, try putting a frozen turkey in hot oil. Hint, do NOT do that! There are some hilarious videos on the internet, but if it happens in real life the explosion isn’t funny at all. I like to use a fresh turkey and even with that I will take the turkey out of the refrigerator for a couple of hours prior to frying to make sure it is at room temperature.
Pre-measure how much oil to put in your fryer
I like to place my turkey in the cold fryer before cooking. Then I fill the fryer with water to get the turkey fully covered. You then pull the turkey out and mark how much water is in the fryer. Then empty the water out. Fully dry the pot and fill the fryer with oil up to your mark.
Fry your turkey outside away from anything that will catch on fire
This seems like an obvious one, but you can’t be too careful. Again there are stories where people have fried a turkey inside or even on a wooden deck that just didn’t end well.
Use a fry oil thermometer and take precaution when lowering the turkey into the oil
Heat your oil to 250 degrees and then slowly lower the turkey in. The biggest risk is the first time you lower the turkey into the oil, with the oil bubbling over and igniting with the flame. I use the hook unit that comes with the fryer and wearing heat resistant cooking gloves and a large sturdy fork to lower the bird in without getting burned. Once the turkey is in, I then bring the oil temperature up to 350 degrees and cook for 35 minutes.
Use an instant-read thermometer to make sure the bird is done.
After the bird has cooked for 35 minutes, I pull it out with the hook, gloves, and fork. Then, using an instant-read thermometer, I make sure the internal temp is 155 degrees. After the turkey is out of the oil it will continue to cook and should reach 165 degrees. The bird should rest for at least 20 to 30 minutes before carving.
Again, use precaution if you decide to fry your turkey this Thanksgiving.
Paul Kenny is the author of Impromptu Friday Nights, A Guide to Supper Clubs, which will release January 30, 2018. For more info, visit http://impromptufridaynights.com